Hakkar Reward; What do you think..

[Inconsiderable]

Hello.

Maybe I missed the discussion, but Hakkar drops a Questitem, like Onyxia, with the following Questrewards:

http://wow.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?witem=19948
http://wow.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?witem=19950
( http://wow.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?witem=19949 unimportant)

Now, with all the Melee Itemization, I thought about getting the Armor Trinket along with the Arena Master Trinket (~1200 physical absorb) to stay alive against Warrior/Rogues. I like the idea; however, I would miss a superb caster damage trinket.

Thoughts?

[Savor]

Don't pass up the spell damage trinket, tbh.

[Ziot]

AP + Toep/Zandalar = 1200 scorch crits, 700 base scorch.

Why pass up on 2x a toep?

[Ziot]

Fuck you two I'm taking the armor trinket.

Judging by the faces on the Warlocks, you aren't getting a trinket. :cry:

[Unamed]

The answer is pretty obvious:

http://www.photodump.com/direct/devinb2k4/warvis.jpg

The melee trinket.

[khan3817]

High strength-based warlocks with Vis'Kag and Improved Firestone probably a little more damage than end-game rogues and Arms warriors imo.

[LaughinMan]

but will the plus on damage be worth the loss of defense comparing the 3 ?

[dNa]

High strength-based warlocks with Vis'Kag and Improved Firestone probably a little more damage than end-game rogues and Arms warriors imo.

Biggest bullshit i EVER heard .... sry, but its so obvious..

[Theldon]

seeing a warlock with that wpn is almost as funny as a paladin with hand of sulfuras

[deathjester]

as disc/holy priest ill take the armor trinket, definitely

[dNa]

Its hot if toep and hakkar talisman stack i guess i take the dmg one but not sure yet 2000armor is also nice, but only sometimes i guess more opinions pls. Btw as i priest i would 100% take the armor trinket its perfekt for priests and a nice combo with the bwl one too i guess :o

[Julemanden]

What have I done

In a month or two all priests will have 5000+ armor :(

[Ziot]

The melee trinket is trash, it can up the damage you CAN do, but it doesn't guarantee it. The caster trinket guarantees extra spell damage on every spell.

[ghost7]

I'm mage :P
caster thrinkt use together with MC's cause good damage~~

[Apotheosis]

Cyberia, it pains me to see Paladins with Sulfuras as well. Oh well, not my build, not up to me.

It depends on which caster I was. If I was a Mage or Lock, I'd go wiht the spell damage trinket. If I were a Priest, I'd go wiht the armor trinket. Up to you guys, though.

[BarryManilow]

any warriors w/ the tank trinket comment on how it is? i already got the shield off hakkar its teh sexy :)

[IeU]

The melee trinket is trash, it can up the damage you CAN do, but it doesn't guarantee it. The caster trinket guarantees extra spell damage on every spell.

lol ?

+40dmg to min and max dmg every 2 minutes is trash ?

[Shakkha77]

if you are lucky, it can do up to 420damage every 2 minutes, that's 3.5dps. That is if you manage to hit 20times in 20seconds...

If you proc twice maelstrom trinket in 2 minutes you out damage that.

blackhand breadth as well out dps it easily, maybe even hand of justice for rogue should be better, i am too lazy to look up figures, or compare it to all the melee trinkets, but it really feels sub-par

[BarryManilow]

wow a priest got it? :) im one of 2 main tanks and i got yelled at last nite by 2 mages for rolling on it

i guess that helps prevent the priest focus fire in AB?

[moto]

The melee trinket is trash, it can up the damage you CAN do, but it doesn't guarantee it. The caster trinket guarantees extra spell damage on every spell.

lol ?

+40dmg to min and max dmg every 2 minutes is trash ?

Yes, the trinket is horrible. It doesn't add to the the weapon damage , it adds to the tooltip damage. Instead of hitting 1000 auto shot crits I hit for 1050, whoopity doo.

[RubiksCube]

Does it work with physical dots?

I.E. get 5 combo points than trinket -> rupture for +40 dmg per tick?

[dNa]

got the dmg trinket now using it with toep it stacks and i luv it, i am still a glasscannon without any def but i guess blizz wont fix that till version 2.5 or sth items doesnt help even with 4k armor ms focus is just broken shit and makes pvp zero fun sometimes if you are known as a dmg dealer or healer :s